The ‘problem’ with disappearing ships seems to be this: If there is more than one way ‘off’ a planet, the fleet can retreat in any direction, even to a hostile territory. Each fleet seems to make this decision seperately, so with four fleets, you could have 1, 2, 3, or 4 of them make it back safely, or not. If a fleet retreats to a hostile planet, it just disappears. Stupid captains.
Says full 1.49 but Ignore my 2nd post in this thread - I was in the red when the battle timed out so technically I lost and my fleet should have been wiped out.
See my other thread - I’ve created a nice bug list for you.